Do the math first, then talk about location. Two candidate warehouses: one is 2 kilometers from the highway exit, the other is 12. One-way difference: five minutes. The rent? The closer one costs 0.15 dollars more per square foot per month. On a 50,000-square-foot building, that is 90,000 dollars a year in extra rent. Is five minutes worth 90,000 dollars? Plenty of people will answer from gut feel. Gut feel doesn't count. The numbers do.

Here is the calculation, built on the actual trip counts from a deal I worked on — swap in your own numbers. Assume 50 truck visits a day, each round trip adding 4 kilometers each way, over 300 working days a year. That is 120,000 extra kilometers a year. A heavy truck burns roughly 35 liters per 100 kilometers, so that's 42,000 extra liters of diesel. At 1.05 dollars a liter, fuel alone costs an extra 44,000 dollars a year. Driver time? Ten extra minutes per round trip, 50 visits a day, comes to 2,500 hours a year. At 28 dollars an hour, that's another 70,000 dollars. Fuel plus labor: 114,000 dollars a year. And that is before tire wear, vehicle depreciation, and late-delivery penalties.

Run it the other way and the closer building is actually cheaper: 90,000 dollars more rent against 114,000 dollars saved in fuel and labor — a net saving of about 24,000 dollars a year. But don't sign anything yet, because that answer rests on one assumption: 50 visits a day. If your building only sees 20 visits a day, fuel plus labor only comes to about 45,000 dollars a year, well short of the 90,000 rent gap — and the farther building wins. I worked out the break-even point under these assumptions: roughly 39 visits a day. Below it, take the farther building. Above it, take the closer one.

When Trip Counts Are Low, Five Minutes Is Worth Nothing

In 2023 I ran this math for an auto-parts client. His building saw fewer than 15 visits a day — big batches, few trips, drivers in and out on a loose schedule. The rent gap between the two candidates was more than 70,000 dollars a year. Fuel and labor savings came to barely 30,000. I told him the money was wasted on the closer building — take the farther one, and put the rent savings into two extra months of safety stock so peak season never stocks out. He listened. Three years on, that building is still working fine.

The opposite mistake happened the same year. A fast-moving consumer goods client picked a building 14 kilometers from the highway exit because the rent was cheap. Eighty-plus visits a day, up to 120 at peak. Within the first month, drivers were complaining: the rural road jammed up morning and evening, and a one-way trip regularly took 25 minutes. Worse, carriers charge by the trip, and the extra road time ended up baked into their rates. Within three months, transport costs were running nearly 20 percent over budget. Most of the rent savings went straight back out through freight.

So my judgment is this: distance on the map is a fake number. Trip density is the real one. The more visits a day your building handles, the more every minute closer to the highway is worth. For a low-volume building, cheap rent is the only logic that matters.

Three Costs Beyond Fuel Savings People Forget to Count

The first is the on-time cost. A building far from the highway leaves drivers with more variables on the road, and appointment times slip. One client measured it: on-time arrivals at the farther building ran 12 percentage points lower than at the closer one. A late truck queues at the dock, the queue delays the next truck, and by peak season the whole afternoon is firefighting. That cost never shows up on a fuel invoice. It shows up in overtime pay and customer complaints.

The second is the carrier quote. Many carriers price by zone, and an address far from the highway with poor roads either carries a remote surcharge or gets bumped into a higher rate tier. You negotiate rent by the square foot, then discover at the transport table that part of your rent savings was pocketed by the carrier. Before signing anything, send both candidate addresses to three carriers for quotes. The difference stares you in the face.

The third is hiring. This one gets ignored the most. A building far from the highway is usually far from town too. Longer commutes, harder hiring, higher turnover. One building I know ran three people short on nights for months because of its location, and covered it with overtime — more than 8,000 dollars a month in extra pay. If you can't staff the building, it doesn't matter how much fuel you saved, because the freight isn't going out the door.

Cost item Closer to highway Farther (50 visits/day)
Annual rent 90,000 dollars more Baseline
Annual fuel 44,000 dollars saved 44,000 dollars extra
Driver labor 70,000 dollars saved 70,000 dollars extra
On-time performance and overtime Relatively stable Extra overtime and penalties
Annual net About 24,000 dollars saved About 24,000 dollars extra

Here is a method you can use directly, with your own numbers, in three steps. Step one: work out the rent gap — how much more per year. Step two: work out the cost per truck visit — fuel plus driver time for one extra round trip. Step three: divide the rent gap by the per-visit cost. That gives you the break-even number of visits per day. If your real volume is above it, take the closer building. Below it, take the farther one.

One more thing: don't calculate for today's volume alone — calculate for the volume across the lease. A lease runs three to five years. A building doing 20 visits a day today could be doing 60 in two years. Pick the farther building on today's numbers, and when volume doubles, fuel and labor double with it — while the rent gap stays exactly where it was. Before signing, ask yourself one question: over these three years, what is the highest trip count this building will most likely reach? Run the math on that number, and the answer will hold up.

So how much does five minutes closer to the highway really save in a year? At 50 visits a day, fuel saves about 44,000 dollars — fuel and labor together, about 114,000. But those five minutes are worth nothing on their own. What they are worth depends entirely on how many trucks you run a day. Until you have counted your trip density, any location decision is a gamble.

By Lao Zhou, Logistics Cost Analyst