We had a client, a home-goods supplier doing a few million dollars a year, who had just landed shelf space at two big US retailers. The compliance notice gave them 30 days to get on EDI or lose the first order. They signed with a provider in a hurry. The first month's bill was a little over $400, and they felt fine about it. By year two the bill was over $2,000 a month, and the owner came to me asking where the money was going and whether they could switch. I told him yes, they could switch — but only after we worked out what all three routes actually cost. Otherwise the next provider would be just as expensive.
EDI Service Provider Routes: Three Completely Different Bills
One thing first: neither SPS nor TrueCommerce publishes a price list. Pricing is quoted per customer, based on partner count, volume, and mapping complexity. The figures below come from third-party comparison sites and public industry sources — treat them as negotiation reference points, and confirm the latest pricing on each vendor's official site before you budget anything.
SPS sells peace of mind. Third-party listings put Fulfillment at roughly $99 a month to start, with a basic tier around $20 a month — but that is only the ticket in. The real money sits behind it: implementation and testing run about $1,500 to $3,000 per retailer added, and mid-market monthly bills commonly land between $600 and $6,000 depending on partners and document types. Its network holds 80,000-plus partner connections, the deepest retail coverage in North America, and onboarding takes about four weeks for the first partner and two to three weeks for each one after that. It fits suppliers who want to say "don't explain the technology, just get me compliant."
TrueCommerce looks friendlier at the door. Third-party listings put its web EDI at about $19.95 to $20 a month, with ERP-integrated plans around $349 to $1,200-plus a month. Its model is a fixed monthly fee plus per-document charges: published tiers run about $0.25 per document at low volume, stepping down to $0.05 at high volume, with 997 acknowledgments free, and mapping, testing, and setup around $750 per trading partner as a one-time fee. It claims 120,000 to 180,000-plus partner nodes. Two things to watch: users report onboarding stretching to eight to twelve weeks or more, slower than advertised, and per-document billing means your peak-season volume spike shows up directly on the invoice.
Direct AS2 — building your own connection to each retailer with no network in the middle — is the scary one up front. Public sources put the software and server investment at roughly $15,000 to $35,000, with six to twelve weeks to go live. But once it is built, there are no per-document fees and no per-kilocharacter charges. Traditional VANs bill about $0.05 to $0.15 per kilocharacter, so the bigger your documents, the more you pay; direct AS2 wipes that line off the bill. The price is headcount: certificate renewals, map changes, and a 2 a.m. outage all become your team's problem.
Here is the comparison table I hand clients before they negotiate:
| Cost item | SPS | TrueCommerce | Direct AS2 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Starting monthly fee | ~$99/month | ~$20/month | None |
| Adding a partner | ~$1,500–$3,000 implementation each | ~$750 mapping each | Your own mapping labor |
| Document/traffic fees | Usage-based, rises with volume | ~$0.25–$0.05 per doc, volume tiers | None |
| Upfront investment | Low | Low | ~$15,000–$35,000 |
| Time to go live | ~4 weeks first partner | Users report 8–12+ weeks | 6–12 weeks |
| Hidden cost | Bill grows with every partner | Peak volume inflates the bill | Staffing, certificates, outage cover |
Three hypothetical scenarios, three different answers
Starting price alone will mislead you, so let me run three hypothetical scenarios. These are illustrative estimates built on the public rate ranges above — get a written quote before you commit to any number.
Scenario one: a small supplier with two retailers and about 800 documents a month. On SPS, monthly fees plus amortized implementation land around $10,000 to $15,000 in year one. On TrueCommerce, monthly fees plus document charges come to roughly $6,000 to $9,000. On direct AS2, the upfront investment alone starts at $15,000 before you count staffing — the most expensive option in year one. At this size, do not build. Pick the cheaper managed provider.
Scenario two: a mid-size supplier with eight retailers and about 8,000 documents a month. The SPS bill climbs hard, with implementation amortized in — year one can reach $30,000 to $50,000. TrueCommerce drops into its cheaper per-document tiers, landing around $20,000 to $30,000. Direct AS2 runs roughly $25,000 to $40,000 in year one, about even with the providers — but from year two onward there are no per-document fees, and the curves split. This is the crossover zone, and it is worth a proper three-way quote.
Scenario three: a 3PL handling EDI for 40-plus clients, over 100,000 documents a month. Provider billing turns ugly here. Per-partner pricing charges you for every client you add; per-document pricing adds thousands of dollars in a peak month. Direct AS2, once the first-year investment is amortized, leaves only staffing and maintenance each year — the cheapest total bill. One 3PL client of ours made exactly this move: their VAN kilocharacter bill used to top $5,000 in a peak month, and after the switch that line went to zero.
The counterintuitive truth is that the cheapest starting price usually produces the most expensive total cost. An EDI bill is not priced on the day you sign. It is priced on how many partners and how much volume you will have three years from now. Every owner who only asks "how much a month?" comes back in year two asking why the bill doubled.
There is one more cost most people forget: the contract itself. Last year a client called me because their provider wanted a 40 percent price increase and they wanted out. I read the contract and shook my head — the auto-renewal clause sat on page nine, requiring written notice 90 days ahead, and they had missed the window. They were locked in for another year. Another client had a salesperson promise "free partner adds" verbally, while the contract said "billed at standard rates." Three months of arguing got nowhere. None of this is a technology problem. It is a signing-day problem. My rule now: get three things written into an attachment — a cap on year-two pricing, the per-partner add price, and the early-exit terms. Verbal promises do not count. Ink counts.
Which EDI Service Provider Route for Which Size
Here is the framework I actually use, based on two numbers: partner count and monthly document volume.
One to three partners and under 2,000 documents a month: pick a managed provider. SPS or TrueCommerce depends on who you connect to — if a retailer insists on the SPS network, accept it; if your partners are spread out and budget is tight, TrueCommerce's lower entry point is friendlier. Do not build at this size. Your own staff costs more than the provider.
Three to ten partners and 2,000 to 20,000 documents a month: get quotes from both routes and compare three-year totals, not year one. Many providers discount year one and reset pricing in year two, so lock the year-two price in the contract before you sign.
Ten-plus partners and over 20,000 documents a month, or if you are a 3PL connecting EDI on behalf of clients, evaluate direct AS2 seriously. The test is simple: is one year of your in-house staffing plus maintenance less than 70 percent of what the provider charges in a year? Below 70 percent, building wins. Above it, keep outsourcing. And one more rule: if a major customer requires direct AS2, building is not a choice. It is mandatory.
One last warning: switching costs more than choosing. Moving providers means re-mapping, re-testing, and re-certifying with each retailer — allow two to four weeks per partner, and never attempt it in peak season. Before you sign anything, ask: how long is the term, what is the early-exit penalty, and can I take my maps and data with me? Ask those three questions and the salesperson will know they are dealing with a professional — and the quote usually gets more honest.
Next time you negotiate an EDI contract, ask these three things: is the year-two price locked? What exactly does one more partner cost? If my volume doubles in peak season, how much does the bill multiply? Ask first, sign second.
By Susan, 3PL Sales Director







